← Back to Blog
review
Priya Mehta
Priya Mehta
· April 18, 2026 17 min read

RakeTrades vs Scarface Trades 2026: Head-to-Head Day Trading Community Comparison

Disclaimer: This is an independent review based on publicly available information. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our analysis.

You're comparing two of the most talked-about premium day trading communities on Whop right now. Both RakeTrades Exclusive Price and Scarface Trades Premium charge $175-$200/month, both focus on price action day trading, and both claim to prepare you for prop firm challenges. But after analyzing their structures, member feedback, and educational approaches, I can tell you they're built for different types of traders.

RakeTrades is Connor Callan's prop-firm-focused operation with 12,389 members and a perfect 5.0-star rating across 331 reviews. Scarface Trades Premium is TonyMontana's larger ecosystem with 4,810 Whop members, 374K YouTube subscribers, and a structured Accelerator program backed by seven years of trading experience.

The real question isn't which is "better" — it's which fits your trading timeline, learning style, and account goals.

Key Facts

Quick Verdict

Best for prop firm prep: RakeTrades Exclusive Price — Connor's entire structure is built around passing funded account challenges, with strategies systematized for drawdown rules and consistency metrics.

Best for structured learning: Scarface Trades Premium — The Accelerator program breaks down advanced concepts into digestible modules, ideal if you need a clear curriculum path.

Price: RakeTrades at $175/month beats Scarface's $200/month, saving you $25 monthly or $300/year.

Bottom line: RakeTrades wins on rating, price, and prop firm focus. Scarface wins on social proof, team size, and structured education. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize live application or curriculum progression.

If you're ready to commit and prop firm success is your primary goal, RakeTrades Exclusive Price offers the most direct path at $175/month with strategies specifically designed for funded account rules.

Pros and Cons

RakeTrades Pros

RakeTrades Cons

Scarface Trades Pros

Scarface Trades Cons

What You're Actually Comparing: Two Different Day Trading Community Models

This isn't a typical day trading comparison where one community is clearly superior. Both RakeTrades Exclusive Price and Scarface Trades Premium deliver legitimate price action education with active founders and daily live sessions. The difference is structural philosophy.

RakeTrades operates as a tight prop-firm-focused operation. Connor Callan built the entire community around one question: how do I pass a funded account challenge and keep it? Every strategy, risk parameter, and trade setup gets filtered through prop firm rules first. If it doesn't work under 5% max drawdown and 10% profit target constraints, it doesn't make the cut.

Scarface Trades runs more like a trading academy. TonyMontana's Accelerator program breaks down day trading into modules with progression paths, FAQ sections, and structured lesson delivery. You're not just watching live trades — you're working through a curriculum designed to build foundational understanding before moving to advanced concepts.

From my analysis of member feedback across both communities, RakeTrades members talk about "challenge prep" and "drawdown management" constantly. Scarface members reference "module completion" and "course progression." That tells you everything about how each community approaches education.

Pricing Breakdown: $175 vs $200 Monthly

RakeTrades Exclusive Price comes in at $175/month through our link, down from the standard $199. That's a $24 monthly saving, or $288 annually if you stick with it for a full year. Over two years — a realistic timeframe to truly master day trading and prop firm rules — you save $576.

Scarface Trades Premium holds firm at $200/month with no discount tiers or promotional pricing. For twelve months, you're paying $2,400 total.

The $25 monthly difference seems small until you remember that many prop firm challenges cost $150-$500 each. That pricing gap pays for roughly half a challenge attempt every two months. When you're funding multiple challenge attempts while learning, every $25 matters.

Neither community offers a cheaper test tier, which honestly frustrates me. Both charge premium prices but give you no way to sample the teaching style or community vibe before full commitment. At $175-$200/month, I'd expect at least a week-long trial or a $49 introductory month. You don't get that here.

Education Structure: Live Application vs Structured Curriculum

RakeTrades centers around daily live trading sessions where Connor trades his own account and explains decision-making in real time. You're watching entries, exits, stop placement, and position sizing as market conditions unfold. The education happens through repetition and pattern recognition rather than formal lessons.

The 3-step entry model Connor teaches at RakeTrades isn't revolutionary — but the way he systematizes it for prop firm consistency rules is what makes it actually useful under pressure. You're learning to identify high-probability setups that fit within 1% risk parameters and can be executed during the New York session without babysitting charts all day.

Based on publicly available information about the community structure, members get access to recorded sessions, community discussion channels, and trade breakdowns. But there's no formal "course" to complete. You learn by showing up daily and absorbing through exposure.

Scarface Trades' Accelerator Program

The Accelerator is Scarface's structured curriculum covering price action fundamentals, trend identification, support and resistance, and advanced concepts like volume profile and order flow. TonyMontana breaks down complex institutional trading concepts into digestible lessons with slides and video walkthroughs.

You're not just watching trades — you're working through modules with clear progression. Finish module one on trend structure before moving to module two on entry timing. The FAQ section addresses common sticking points that trip up new traders.

For someone who needs structure and gets overwhelmed by jumping straight into live sessions, this matters. The Accelerator gives you a roadmap. You know exactly what to learn next instead of trying to piece together education from random live streams.

But here's the tradeoff: structured curricula can feel slower. If you already understand price action basics and just need refinement for prop firm rules, working through foundational modules might feel like paying $200/month to relearn concepts you've already studied.

Strategy Replicability Index: How Easy to Actually Execute

I measure every community's strategies using my proprietary Strategy Replicability Index — four criteria totaling 10 points that tell you whether a regular trader can actually implement what's being taught.

RakeTrades SRI: 7.6/10

Rule Clarity: 2.1/2.5 — Connor's 3-step entry model has specific criteria for trend confirmation, pullback structure, and entry trigger. Not perfectly mechanical, but clear enough to replicate without constant hand-holding.

Screen Time Required: 2.0/2.5 — Focuses on New York session (9:30am-12pm EST), so you need three hours daily. That's manageable if you have morning availability but excludes anyone with traditional 9-5 office jobs.

Capital Requirement: 2.2/2.5 — Designed for prop firm accounts starting at $5K-$10K, which means strategies work with smaller position sizes and tighter risk. You can practice on a $2K personal account using micro contracts.

Emotional Difficulty: 1.3/2.5 — Prop firm rules create psychological pressure. You're constantly aware of drawdown limits, which makes it harder to execute stops without hesitation. This is realistic but tough for beginners.

Scarface Trades SRI: 7.2/10

Rule Clarity: 1.9/2.5 — The Accelerator teaches concepts more than mechanical rules. You'll understand why a setup works, but translating that into "I enter when X, Y, and Z align" takes more personal interpretation.

Screen Time Required: 1.8/2.5 — Also focuses on morning session, but TonyMontana's teaching covers multiple timeframes and setups. You might need more screen time to identify all the patterns being taught across different market conditions.

Capital Requirement: 2.3/2.5 — Similar to RakeTrades, strategies work on standard day trading accounts. No requirement for huge capital to execute safely.

Emotional Difficulty: 1.2/2.5 — Learning through structured curriculum is less stressful than live execution, but the Accelerator's advanced concepts can feel overwhelming. Knowing the theory and executing under pressure are different challenges.

RakeTrades edges ahead by 0.4 points because Connor's prop-firm-specific systematization makes strategies slightly more mechanical and replicable. Scarface's conceptual depth is valuable but requires more personal translation into actionable rules.

Community Size and Engagement: Numbers Don't Tell the Whole Story

RakeTrades has 12,389 members on Whop — nearly three times Scarface's 4,810. That larger member count means more trade ideas flowing through discussion channels, more real-time feedback, and higher odds someone's watching the same ticker you're considering.

But Scarface has 374K YouTube subscribers and 320K Instagram followers. That social media presence translates to massive free educational content libraries. You can watch dozens of TonyMontana's trade breakdowns, strategy explanations, and market analysis videos before ever paying $200/month. That transparency builds trust.

According to community feedback visible on Reddit and Whop reviews, RakeTrades members describe a tighter, more focused community culture. Scarface members mention benefiting from the larger team (nine staff members) providing more support coverage across time zones.

Get the Weekly Edge

Join traders who read our Sunday market brief. Free, no spam.

Neither community has public discontent or major complaints about inactive founders. Both Connor and TonyMontana appear actively engaged based on member reports.

Prop Firm Preparation: The Deciding Factor for Many Traders

If passing a prop firm challenge is your primary goal, RakeTrades Exclusive Price is purpose-built for that outcome. Connor's entire teaching framework revolves around prop firm constraints: 5% max daily drawdown, 10% max overall drawdown, profit targets, and consistency requirements.

Every strategy gets stress-tested against these rules. Can you execute it without risking more than 1% per trade? Does it generate enough edge to hit profit targets without overleveraging? Will it work when you can't revenge trade after a loss because you're worried about hitting drawdown limits?

That focus matters because I failed three prop firm challenges in 2019 using strategies that worked fine on my personal account. The difference was psychological pressure and rule constraints. What RakeTrades teaches — position sizing discipline, stop placement that respects drawdown math, and setup selection that tolerates losing streaks — is exactly what I needed back then.

Scarface Trades Premium covers prop firm preparation but doesn't center the entire community around it. The Accelerator teaches you to trade — then you adapt those skills to prop firm rules. That works, but it's less direct.

For traders primarily interested in day trading education with prop firms as a secondary goal, Scarface's broader approach makes sense. For traders who specifically need to pass a challenge in the next 90 days, RakeTrades' laser focus is more efficient.

Check out our Scarface Trades vs Jdub Trades 2026: Which Day Trading Community Wins? comparison for more insight into how Scarface approaches different trading styles.

What You're Not Getting with Either Community

Let's be honest about limitations. Neither RakeTrades nor Scarface Trades offers options-specific education. If you want to trade stock options with strategies like spreads, iron condors, or earnings plays, look at Stock Levels University Monthly instead — they focus specifically on options with JRGREATNESS' Mastermind Course covering directional and non-directional strategies.

Neither community provides automated signals or trade alerts. You're learning to identify setups yourself through education and pattern recognition. If you want someone telling you "buy this ticker now," these aren't signal services.

Both communities lack cheaper entry tiers. At $175-$200/month with no trial period, you're making a significant financial commitment based on reviews, social media content, and reputation alone. That's a barrier for beginners who can't comfortably allocate $2,000+ annually to education.

Neither publishes verified P&L statements showing founder performance over multiple years. You're trusting member testimonials and social proof rather than audited track records. That doesn't mean the education is ineffective — but it means you can't verify claims with hard data.

Who Should Choose RakeTrades

You'll get the most value from RakeTrades Exclusive Price if you're specifically preparing for prop firm challenges and need strategies systematized around drawdown rules. The $175/month pricing, perfect 5.0-star rating, and Connor's prop-firm-first teaching approach make it the most direct path to funded account success.

It's also the better choice if you learn best through repetition and live application rather than structured curriculum. Watching Connor trade daily and absorbing patterns through exposure suits traders who get overwhelmed by formal coursework.

The larger 12,389-member community means more active discussion and trade idea flow. If community engagement and peer learning matter to you, RakeTrades delivers that at scale.

Who Should Choose Scarface Trades

Scarface Trades Premium makes more sense if you value structured curriculum and need clear module progression to stay on track. The Accelerator program gives you a roadmap — finish module one before module two — which helps if you're the type who gets lost trying to learn from random YouTube videos and live streams.

The massive social proof (374K YouTube, 320K Instagram) means you can evaluate TonyMontana's teaching style extensively before paying $200/month. Watch his free content for weeks to confirm you resonate with his explanations and personality.

The nine-member staff team provides more support coverage if you need help outside standard hours or want faster response times on questions.

For a comprehensive comparison of how Scarface stacks up against another major premium trading community, read our Jdub Trades Premium vs Scarface Trades Premium 2026: Head-to-Head Comparison article.

The Pricing Reality Check

Both communities are expensive. $175-$200/month equals $2,100-$2,400 annually. Add in prop firm challenge fees ($150-$500 per attempt), charting software ($50-$100/month), and your personal trading capital, and you're looking at $5,000+ in first-year costs before you ever generate income.

That's the honest math. Day trading isn't cheap to learn properly.

The question is whether paying for structured education prevents you from making expensive mistakes. I spent $6,000 on failed prop firm challenges in 2019-2020 trying to learn through trial and error. If $2,100 in education helps you avoid even half that loss, it's a positive expected value decision.

But only if you actually implement what you learn. Paying $200/month to watch videos occasionally without practicing setups on a simulator or small account is wasted money. These communities work when you treat them like a job, not Netflix.

At $175/month with a 5.0-star rating from actual members, I honestly don't know how long RakeTrades holds that exclusive pricing — most premium communities raise prices as their member count and reputation grow.

How These Communities Stack Up Against Alternatives

RakeTrades and Scarface aren't your only options in the premium day trading community space. Jdub Trades Premium also charges $200/month with 15,150 members and a 4.9-star rating from 457 reviews. Jdub focuses on futures and options with an Accelerator Course similar to Scarface's structure.

For traders specifically interested in stock options rather than futures or equities day trading, Stock Levels University Monthly at $200/month offers JRGREATNESS' Mastermind Course covering directional and non-directional options strategies with a proprietary RT Levels Indicator.

The key differentiator for RakeTrades is the prop firm specialization and the $175 exclusive pricing. The key differentiator for Scarface is the structured Accelerator curriculum and massive free educational content library on YouTube.

Read our full Scarface Trades Review 2026: TonyMontana's Day Trading Community Tested for a deeper breakdown of what you get inside the community.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is RakeTrades better than Scarface Trades for beginners?

Neither community is specifically designed for absolute beginners with zero trading knowledge. Both assume you understand basic market mechanics, order types, and chart reading. That said, Scarface's Accelerator program provides more structured foundational education, making it slightly more beginner-friendly. RakeTrades works better if you already grasp basics and need to refine execution for prop firm challenges. If you're completely new, consider starting with free educational resources before committing $175-$200/month.

Which community has better live trading sessions?

Both offer daily live trading sessions, but the format differs. RakeTrades' sessions focus on real-time trade execution with Connor explaining decisions as market conditions unfold — you're learning through watching active trading. Scarface's live streams combine trade execution with educational commentary and Q&A, functioning more like interactive lessons. If you want pure execution focus, RakeTrades. If you want execution plus teaching context, Scarface.

Can I join both communities simultaneously?

Technically yes, but at $375/month combined cost, that's $4,500 annually for education alone. From a practical standpoint, most traders struggle to fully implement teachings from even one community — splitting attention between two different approaches and attending multiple daily sessions creates information overload. Better to commit fully to one community for 3-6 months, master their system, then evaluate whether additional perspectives are worth the cost.

Do either communities offer refunds if I'm not satisfied?

Based on publicly available information, neither community advertises a specific refund policy or satisfaction guarantee. Most Whop-based communities charge monthly subscriptions that you can cancel anytime, but you're responsible for the current month's payment. Before joining, verify the current cancellation and refund terms directly on their respective Whop pages, as policies can change.

Which community is better for passing FTMO or similar prop firm challenges?

RakeTrades Exclusive Price is specifically built around prop firm preparation with strategies systematized for drawdown rules, consistency metrics, and profit targets. Every trade setup Connor teaches is filtered through the question "will this work under prop firm constraints?" Scarface covers prop firm preparation as one component of broader day trading education. If your sole goal is passing an FTMO, MyForexFunds, or similar challenge within the next 90 days, RakeTrades' specialized focus is more efficient.

Final Verdict: RakeTrades Wins on Focus, Scarface Wins on Structure

After analyzing both premium day trading communities, RakeTrades Exclusive Price delivers better value if prop firm success is your primary goal. The $175/month pricing beats Scarface's $200, the perfect 5.0-star rating from 331 reviews shows consistent member satisfaction, and Connor's entire teaching philosophy centers on funded account preparation. You're paying less for more specialized, directly applicable education.

Scarface Trades Premium wins if you need structured curriculum with clear progression paths and value massive social proof before committing. The Accelerator program, nine-member support team, and 374K YouTube subscriber library provide comprehensive education beyond just prop firm preparation.

Both are legitimate, active communities with engaged founders and daily live sessions. Your choice comes down to learning style (live application vs structured curriculum) and primary goal (prop firm specialization vs broader day trading education).

For most traders focused on achieving funded account status, RakeTrades' $175/month exclusive pricing, higher rating, and prop-firm-first approach make it the more efficient path. Start there, master Connor's systematized strategies under prop firm constraints, and pass your challenges before considering whether additional perspectives are worth $200/month elsewhere.

Get the Weekly Edge

Join traders who read our Sunday market brief. Free, no spam.

Priya Mehta
Priya Mehta Day Trading Strategies & Prop Firm Education

Priya left her finance analyst job to pursue day trading full-time — and promptly failed 3 prop firm challenges in a row. That humbling experience made her obsessive about finding trading education that actually prepares you for funded accounts. She now writes in-depth strategy breakdowns and reviews trading communities specifically through the lens of prop firm readiness and day trading consistency.